I have debated for almost as long as I have been writing this blog whether or not I should comment on the Post Secret movement. I have decided to go ahead and make this post, but not link to any Post Secret material because sometimes the “secrets” contain material that would be inappropriate for some people.

For those that do not know, since at least 2005, a man named Frank Warren has allowed people to mail confessions on postcards to his home. He in turn, took those postcards and organized them into books. People found both humor and support in reading the confessions of others, as people found they were not alone in their struggles. People began placing confession postcards inside of library and bookstore copies of Warren’s books for others to find. A Post Secret website and mobile app were developed. Post Secret rallies are community events that draw multitudes of people. People have been rescued from the brink of suicide, and found encouragement and love. And, of course, many have relieved their guilty consciences, but is that enough?

I believe, outside of the Roman Catholic Church the sacrament of confession, now called reconciliation, is not formally practiced, and last I heard from a priest in my area, his Friday night confession is not well attended. At best, we Protestants practice “accountability.” I think Mr. Warren may have filled a gap that the church left open, but he provides a bridge without a foundation. Confession does relieve the feeling of guilt, but only forgiveness removes actual guilt. Frank Warren can neither absolve anyone, nor provide the satisfaction to pay for anyone’s guilt. That ability is only found in Jesus (Luke 5:20-25, 1 John 2:2).

• Do you practice confession in your church?
• If so, in what ways?
• What is causes us to lack in this area? lack of community or transparency, fear, something else?
• Are there any lessons we can take from Warren’s approach?